Date: 28th November 2010 at 6:00pm
Written by:

Welcome to the seventh issue of The Red Report, the round table discussion of all things Manchester United by your favourite United blogs: The Busby Way, Stretford-End, Bangalore To Old Trafford, ManUtd24, and Red Force Rising.

This week we look focus on three players – one currently playing for the club; one out on loan; and one true Red legend. After three defeats in four games we also assess what’s going on at our rivals, Chelsea.

tends to split opinion amongst everyone – fans, pundits and the media. Amidst rumours of a potential loan move in January we ask the question – what does his future hold? I stress this topic was chosen before the game against Blackburn

Chudi | The Busby Way: If ever there was a shut your mouth moment then yesterday was it. has a lot of detractors and rightly so as he hasn’t developed as we had expected. In his first season his performances lead us to sing of his toilet habits involving a certain Arsenal player and even though it may be in jest even those of us with the rosiest of rose tinted specs can’t truly believe it. Then he plays like he did yesterday and you start to see what kind of player he can be, surging runs, good positive passing, good ball retention etc.

I was starting to lose patience with many people had too but a tantalising performance like yesterday’s whets the appetite and buys him extra time, he is only 22 so the ability to consistently perform like that isn’t going to be there but we just hope he can play more like that more often than not.

Doron | Stretford-End: My thoughts on are not some knee-jerk reaction to his performance against Blackburn. In fact, for some time now I’ve been singing his praises and almost making it my mission to get Reds on his side.

At only 22 he’s a superb talented with heaps of unfulfilled potential. I believe he has been too hastily written off by people recently. It’s very hard to judge a player who is in and out of the side without a consistent run, let alone a player who has had some bad injuries. It’s true that the jury are still very much out to make their verdict on but played in the correct position for a consistent run will give the best conditions for him to be judged.

My pro-Anderson propaganda started in July and I decided it was necessary to update it on Friday in a new blog.

Siddarth | Bangalore to Old Trafford: Ando’s performance against Blackburn should put to rest all speculation of him leaving the club for now, it was a glimpse of what he is capable of, he was the driving force in midfield and that sublime pass for Nani’s goal just summed up his day, just excellent!

Like Nani, he’s struggled to settle in but he’s slowly finding his feet, and all he needs is a long run of games in the first team to help him improve, and things look very positive in that sense, if Ando can continue to perform like he did against Blackburn, then I don’t think we need to look far for a successor to Paul Scholes!

TG | ManUtd24: I really hope Anderson stays at the club. He has much more to offer, as he showed against Blackburn on Saturday. He played a part in the first two, before setting up the seventh – he got an assist for goodness sakes! I guess his problem is that he never really had a defined position, and so he could never nail down any real consistency. Against Rovers, he made 99 passes – 94 of which were successful – and so he, from that one performance alone, looked a revelation partnering Michael Carrick and playing just a bit behind him. Anderson has a future at the club, he’s had many other good games for the club but I’ll admit he didn’t quite lived up to the ‘next Ronaldinho’ tag. Still, he has more to offer the club – I’d personally be surprised if he leaves in January.

Alan | RedForceRising: Some journos have said he hasn’t lived up to his £17m price tag and maybe they have a point, but they don’t see the potential and talent I see in him. Anderson is probably the only player we have who can play delightful through balls along the ground to unlock a defence and play team mates into dangerous space. He also has the ability to pass the ball just in front of his team mates to run on to, unlike Carrick or Fletcher who tend to pass directly to the target or even slightly behind the target.

Anderson’s all-round game and ability to carry the ball forward are also very, very good. He’s just one of those unfancied players whose abilities tend to get underplayed. However, he really needs to work on his consistency. Energetic and dynamic displays like Yesterday’s haven’t occurred regularly enough and his off-the-ball movement is absolutely criminal at times.

I’m quite convinced this will be Anderson’s make or break season. If he buckles up, stops partying and focuses, he can go on to achieve great things. If he doesn’t, he’s going to become one of those journey men footballers who end up playing in Greece, Turkey and then the Middle East or the MLS.

(For more on Anderson, as well as Rooney and why their return to form and fitness are essential to United’s title aspirations based on tactical factors, please read my blog of the week)

Kyle | Stretford-End: In the middle of the week Anderson was linked with a loan move to Panathinaikos and on Saturday he was putting in what would’ve been a Man of the Match performance if not for Berbatov. Now what he really needs to do is pick up where he’s left off. It’s no secret this is a huge season for Anderson’s future at Old Trafford, and now he’s taken his chance well against Blackburn. Hopefully now he’s earned himself a run of games and can show us why Sir Alex signed him in 2007.

I think one important thing we need to do as fans is to adjust our expectations for the Brazilian. When he first arrived we saw him as an attacking midfielder and expected goals. As he’s developed though, I think it’s become clear that Anderson isn’t going to be the second coming of Ronaldinho that some anticipated. He’s developed into more of a deep-lying play maker. We saw against Blackburn that Anderson is capable of creating chances with his passing. Not only that, but his strength and energetic play makes him a good enforcer as well. He does need to improve his goalscoring certainly even in that role, but I don’t think he’s going to be the goalscoring midfielder we all thought he would be.

That said, I do think Anderson still has a future at United. Just because he hasn’t become the player we expected doesn’t mean he needs to be shown the door. He’s become a different type of player than what we anticipated, but it’s certainly a role that we could use. He had a fantastic game against Blackburn showing why Stretford-End has tirelessly campaigned for him. I look for him to build off of that in the coming weeks.

Clearly, United fans want Anderson to succeed but something just hasn’t clicked yet. Without being too knee-jerky, hopefully yesterday will be the start of a new chapter.

With four goals in three games for Sunderland, Danny Welbeck has hit the headlines. It would appear our loan star is settling in and playing well for his team. Here’s how we think his loan is going as we consider his future:

Alan | RedForceRising: I ran an impromptu poll on Twitter recently asking if United fans would swap him for Jordan Henderson and the 40 0dd replies I received indicated that 60% were not in favour of doing so with 40% being quite emphatic about taking that deal.

The reasons were that he is unlikely to make it as a striker at United, whereas Henderson could make it as a central midfielder or that he simply wasn’t United class and didn’t have the potential to become “United quality”.

For me, we owe it to him to give him that chance. He’s born in Longsight, he’s got bags of pace, good ball control and is starting to find the net regularly. Danny has been doing what you’re supposed to be doing on loan and he’s improved with every game. He’s growing in confidence and it shows in his displays and decision-making. His all-round game is already way ahead of Macheda’s and that’s why Kiko needs to go out on loan next season and Welbeck needs to be at old Trafford where he should get a chance to prove if he has got what it takes to make the step up at United.

TG | ManUtd24: is definitely enjoying his early Christmas present from Fergie. He now has four from his last three; and a reason as to why is that Brucie has played him more centrally. And sure, Bruce will make an offer. I’m still wary though – time will tell whether or not Welbeck can continue to develop. I hope by next season, we have a more mature, disciplined forward because everything else is there already. He needs to build on these performances for the Black Cats, and a couple of goals against our most fierce rivals wouldn’t do him any harm either.

Siddarth | Bangalore to Old Trafford: I had my doubts about Danny, he had never really lived up to all the promise he was showing at the academy and reserves level, he looked a promising prospect but I was always worried that wouldn’t really be able to find a position he’s best at, his attributes were enough to be a winger or a striker, but not exceptional in either position. But his growth physically over the last season has certainly helped him.

He’s now a threat in the air, and physically tough too, and Is finally starting to become the player Sir Alex rates so highly. Guess all he needed was a continuous run of games, and under he’s improved tremendously, I hope we don’t sell him, and bring him back for next season; he’s going to be a real asset to have in the team. I think Macheda could also do with a loan, playing regular first team football; hopefully he can too next season

Doron | Stretford-End: I must confess that I’ve not watched much of Welbeck whilst he’s been on loan at Sunderland. Certainly I started to pay more attention when I saw he was starting against Chelsea, coincidentally the same game he started to make positive headlines. Welbeck first came to prominence in the first team three years ago when he travelled with the squad to the Middle East for Sami Al-Jaber’s testimonial, unfortunately Welbeck missed a penalty in the last minute in that game. Since then he’s often made the most of limited opportunities at United but also been frustrated by his selection as a winger.

This loan move to Sunderland seemed perfect – regular action upfront. Unfortunately it’s taken until the past few games for him to feature upfront rather than on the wing, and he are seeing the rewards. He looks, strong, quick, powerful, clever and with 4 well taken goals in his last 3 games he’s in form. I’ll be keeping a close eye on him over the next few weeks, and maybe at the end of the season United will have a real gem of a player returning.

Kyle | Stretford-End: I wrote a piece about Danny Welbeck recently for Stretford-End, and since then he’s scored again. Welbeck put in some indifferent performances early in his loan with Sunderland, but he’s really started to click in recent weeks notching up four goals in three matches, one of which was against Chelsea. has started using Welbeck up front rather than on the wings, and that move has clearly paid dividends. That perhaps illustrates why Welbeck has failed to establish himself at United thus far where Sir Alex has often used Welbeck on the wings.

My one concern has started to flare up unfortunately. has made public his intentions to try to sign Welbeck on a permanent deal. After all the promise Welbeck has shown in recent weeks it would be a shame if we didn’t bring him back next season. Hopefully, Welbeck’s performances have done the exact opposite and forced himself into Sir Alex’s plans. It’s hard to forget former prospects like Fraizer Campbell and Giuseppe Rossi who were allowed to move on. It would be a real shame if Welbeck follow that path.

Chudi | The Busby Way: I have a friend who feels that the loan spell for Danny Welbeck spells the end of his United career and slowly but surely he is being made to eat his words. Welbeck has shown whilst at the Stadium of Light that he can score goals, something that a few people worried about and the types of goals he is scoring are just as important as he is in the boxing getting them in rather than the spectacular efforts we have seen already. His header yesterday was a quality finish and looking at him it appears the loan spell has done him the world of good as his confidence has risen so many levels. I have always favoured Welbeck over Macheda as I feel as an overall player he offers more with the addition of goals (which if you followed his academy and reserve career you knew he had in him), he looks an even more exciting player. I would like for him to have a future at the club even if he won’t be drawn on talking about it at the moment.

It seems that the club owe it to him to give him the opportunity to perform at Old Trafford.

To read the second part of the Red Report click here