Date: 5th December 2010 at 10:00am
Written by:

Yes, Christmas is finally here.

Well, not really, but we have already entered the festive period and whilst many are counting down to the 25th of December and the New Year, most football fans are counting down to the opening of the winter transfer window! I don’t normally get excited about January transfer windows since they are usually low-key for us, our last major January signings being Patrice Evra and Nemanja Vidic for a total fee of £12.5m but for those who have experienced the Football Manager™ revolution, it can be fun to speculate on squad changes! Here are some thoughts in bullet points:

1. Replacing the old guard: You might have noticed that we have a fair few oldies in our squad who will be most probably retire in a year or two. I think we are well covered for Gary Neville (who hasn’t really been indispensable recently) with Rafael finally showing some kind of consistency. I still hope De Laet has a future at United, given his versatility and promise. Yesterday I read Giggs hinting about this season being his last and we could see problems in ‘replacing’ Giggs and Scholes. We do have Anderson at the moment, but unless Gibson gets more chances, I don’t think we would have enough options in midfield once the Ginger Prince leaves. I am more worried about our left wing. Park is an able winger, but he is more dangerous when he ventures infield and as for Obertan, he also looks better just behind the striker. We are crying out for a natural left-winger. If only Adam Johnson was really unhappy at Eastlands…

2. VDS defying Father Time: Van Der Sar has been a mainstay of the United side for some time now and as he recently turned 40 and with Fergie effectively saying that this season could be his last, we need some changes in the goalkeeping department. With Lindegaard joining us in January, speculation about incoming goalkeepers refuses to go away. We could potentially have an unhappy Kuszczak on our hands too who despite his less than stellar performance against West Ham during the week, I still value and I would be gutted if he didn’t get a crack at the No.1 spot.

If he does leave, I would rather have someone with more experience than Lindegaard. If we are planning to throw cash at this, instead of a young De Gea who admittedly is a tremendous talent, I would rather go for Lloris or even Buffon! Akinfeev looks good too and very experienced for his young age but I don’t know if how long he might take to settle down in North West England.

3. Creative attacking midfielder™: United have been in need of a creative attacking midfielder for years. I don’t remember us ever having a creative attacking midfielder in the last 10 years, not in the mould of the ones we have been linked to. Scholes has been very creative for us, but he likes to lie deep and occasionally venture in the area for a goal or two. Fans and the press have been talking about Sneijder, Ozil and Van Der Vaart who I think would definitely improve our side, but we are not a team who just buy players who would theoretically make us have a stronger starting XI, so we need to think about what exactly we need and what we could realistically acquire.

I, for one, don’t think we are screaming for a creative attacking midfielder we just need more options in the centre of midfield and I think Bastian Schweinsteiger, who is stalling over a new contract, would be an utterly brilliant acquisition… Even Ballack thinks so!

Click here to read the rest of the review

19 responses to “Revolving door: So who’ll be in and out at Old Trafford?”

  1. jonathan says:

    I don’t think wholesale changes are needed. The left wing spot is intriguing, but with Valencia’s return Nani may be able to go back there, although we don’t know to which degree of success. Hard call, but if we do get someone, the Hungarian guy Rohit and Chudi were raving about seems an interesting prospect.

    You raise an interesting point in that we’ve never really used a attacking midfielder. There’s no doubt we’re lacking one, but do we need one? Additionally, we have Cleverley likely coming back in January and I trust Eikrem should see some first team action before the season’s over.

    I guess I’m 50/50 whether we need outside help for these positions. It’s a hard call. But I wouldn’t complaine if we signed Pastore!

    I have no problem hanging onto Brown, O’Shea and Park if they’re content being outside the first team. It’s good to have utility players who are versitle and don’t fuss about being outiside of the favoured starting XI.

    As things stand, Giggs and Neville should probably retire at year’s end and I’m not sure if we’ll see Gibson, kuszczak, Diouf returning next year.

  2. Red Isaiah says:

    Most of the suggestion here are all crap and seem to come from non-united fans. Daring to sell your player who when fit gives you a title winning midfield and propels you to the top of the table even when not fully fit…Carick is the man….how dare you guys say he should be sold. Forget Berba, Evra, and Rooney. At least this four names should not be mentioned on the exit list. On the other hand Obertan has always been awful whenever given the chance how can one put his name as a united winger in place of Giggs,Becks,Ronaldo, Nani…?

  3. bond says:

    pls and pls’utd should not sel carrick,berbatov or evra.but oshea,brown,gibson,anderson,should all be sold,gibson doesn’t knw hw to pass a ball,anderson can’t shoot and can’t mark,and is very bad 4 a midfielder and a brazilian.SAF should please have a look at hamsik,schweinsteigger,and hazard,cos at d moment united defence is dead,forget abt d strikers,it is because services are not been provided.rooney,chicha,berbs,macheda,welbeck can do the not hapy at united performance in recent weeks, blackburn’s an exception.simple:the creativity is gone when we are not playing scholes and giggs.

  4. bond says:

    sorry,i meant to say midfield instead of defence in d above column,our

  5. Danny Salford Red says:

    Red Isaiah, Its a bit rich to criticize Obertan already so harshly then in the next breath reveal you think “Carrick is the man”. An incredibly mediocre man who has little or no affect on any games outcome yes.

  6. Red Isaiah says:

    Obertan should at least be loaned out but Carrick was our regular midfielder when we won made the title three times in a row. Last year he was bad, we ended up losing. This year let’s see how he and us fare. Don’t say it is a coincidence come may!

  7. porno says:

    Congratulations on your site that is always open to innovation. Thank you Free Porn management “porno” Thank you videos

  8. ... says:

    I think this is among the most important info for me. And i’m glad reading your article. But should remark on few general things, The site style is great, the articles is really great : D. Good job, cheers